The Daily Q: Who is in charge of new energy efficiency loans?

Governor Andrew Cuomo announced yesterday that New York consumers seeking to make energy-efficiency upgrades to their homes – such as installing insulation or low-fuel boilers – can now obtain inexpensive loans and repay the debt on their monthly utility bills, as part of a new program called On-Bill Recovery Financing. On-bill financing allows consumers to pay off the cost of the improvements over time, through the savings generated by reduced energy use.

The New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA) will be administering the program, which offers 2.99 percent interest for 5-, 10- and 15-year loans. Central Hudson Gas and Electric, ConEdison, Long Island Power Authority, National Grid, New York State Electric and Gas Corporation, Orange & Rockland, and Rochester Gas and Electric are all participating in on-bill recovery.

Utility companies will now be billing consumers for the loans and must accurately report energy-use reductions on utility bills and credit the savings against the debt owed.

But what happens when they don’t? The New York World asks today: Who will be looking out for consumers who borrow for energy efficiency upgrades through the state’s on-bill financing program?

What we found

If there are any disputes related to the program – be they about bills or the loan payments – NYSERDA is set to step in to mediate and handle any customer complaints. As far as accurately reporting energy savings in homes goes, the utilities are completely removed from the process, involved only to remit back to NYSERDA the loan repayments that appear as line items in the utility bills.

NYSERDA instead will contract the reporting work out to companies accredited by the Building Performance Institute (BPI), and homeowners can pick their contractors as long as they’re recognized by NYSERDA. The BPI-certified contractors typically conduct checks on the energy use of between 10 and 15 percent of their clients to ensure that the right amounts of savings are being recorded.

“Our job is to oversee the program,” said NYSERDA spokesperson Dayle Zatlin. “The utilities just send out the bill, and the contractors help us administer the program.”

Advocates who have weighed in on the legislation behind the program are largely optimistic about the way it will be run. “NYSERDA is supposed to track the energy savings, something they’ve improved at over the years,” said Emmaia Gelman, Green and Equitable Economies Strategist at the Center for Working Families, a policy group whose research informed the state program.

As for the utilities, Gelman notes, they are participating first and foremost because the new legislation “says they have to do this.” The utilities will receive some modest financial incentives from NYSERDA, intended to cover their administrative costs, including upgrades to their billing systems: $100 per loan, plus a fee of 1 percent on the amount of each loan. Based on average loan amount of $8,200, this fee would average about $82 per loan, according to the authority.

“NYSERDA programs are well-audited and verifiable — they’ve been so for a decade in New York,” said Jackson Morris, a senior policy advisor at the Pace Energy and Climate Center who is involved in the implementation of this latest program. “What we’re doing is changing the mechanism, but we don’t have to reinvent the wheel.”

Data Tools


Our work has appeared in…

About TNYW

The New York World focuses on producing data-driven investigative projects.