Why Airbnb is worried — and NYC hosts shouldn’t be

Only a tiny fraction of illegal hotels are investigated, and fewer still face penalties

With Airbnb’s New York operations in the crosshairs of the state Attorney General, the company fought back this week with a media event highlighting the value of its short-term apartment rentals to the city economy. 

Company executives unveiled a new study, which estimates the benefit to the New York City at $632 million a year.

An untold number of those rentals are illegal, under a state law that bans using apartments as short-stay hotels. A recent court ruling determined that a short-term rental through Airbnb or other service is legit as long as the apartment’s legal tenant is also present — but otherwise Airbnb hosts who rent out their apartments are breaking the law.

While company executives are clearly worried, New York City’s roughly 13,500 Airbnb hosts shouldn’t be. Only a tiny fraction of hosts have been the subject of complaints to the Mayor’s Office of Special Enforcement, which investigates menaces to quality of life, and fewer still have actually been penalized.

Between July 4 and October 1 of this year, the office recorded 216 complaints about illegal short-term rentals — some of which tipsters linked to Airbnb postings. At those addresses, just 21 property owners have been cited so far by the Department of Buildings for violations covering that period.

During the same three months, some 167,000 guests in New York City used Airbnb.

As a matter of practice, the Office for Special Enforcement only investigates when it receives reports, a spokesman for the city indicated, which can be made through the city’s 311 hotline, or directly to the office.

We’ve mapped complaints received by the Office of Special Enforcement in between July 4 and October 1, 2013:

One dot = an address that was the subject of an illegal hotel report to the Office of Special Enforcement. Click on a dot to see details on the complaint. Where a location has received more than one report, only one is shown. The New York World has removed references to street and email addresses that appeared in the complaint reports.

An Airbnb spokesman suggested the relatively small number of complaints showed the rentals are welcomed in New York City. “The Airbnb community in New York is respectful and committed to making neighborhoods in all five boroughs even better places to live and visit,” the spokesman said in an email.

Airbnb’s detractors include New York City’s hotel industry, as well as elected officials and housing advocates who argue that Airbnb’s model encourages property owners to convert much needed affordable housing into fly-by-night hotels.

Last month, state Attorney General Eric Scheiderman subpoenaed the company for client information in order to recover what he charged were uncollected taxes. The company is fighting off the order in state Supreme Court.

As tourists (and sometimes bedbugs along for the trip) march through buildings hosting short-term rentals, why isn’t the Mayor’s Office of Special Enforcement hearing more complaints about apartments rented out through Airbnb and its ilk? Tenants are sometimes scared to denounce illegal hotels, said Tom Cayler, who is the chairman of the Illegal Hotel Committee for the West Side Neighborhood Alliance, an organization that advocates for affordable housing. Cayler said his organization has been helping tenants submit such complaints.

“They’re scared, if they’re a rent-stabilized tenant, that if the landlord finds out they’re the ones who complained about this illegal hotel then they’ll be targeted for harassment,” he said.

Enforcement of the law, Cayler added, “should be ramped up, there is no question in my mind.”

New York City represents Airbnb’s largest market wordwide – three times greater than its second market, Paris, an Airbnb official said at the report release.

With expectations, unconfirmed, that the company will eventually have an initial public offering, some observers have remarked Airbnb’s woes in New York could affect the company’s startup valuation, which is currently estimated at as much as $2.5 billion.

Other services frequently mentioned in the Office for Special Enforcement complaints alleging illegal rentals include Wimdu and Home Away.

Add a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


  1. There is no question that the new laws requirements mandating 30 day stays in SRO buildings create the “perfect storm” that forces SRO building Owners to rent to homeless shelters. Failure by the upper west side politicians to change this law back to where it was before will create more homeless shelters by the dozen leading to the further deterioration of the UWS! The people of the West side want tourists! Not tzuris (problems) roll back the laws or grandfather the buildings back to their former status.

  2. So what is the difference between a short term apartment rental and a hotel? At least this is good news for NYC, better business for the hotels if they are closed down.

  3. The issue is getting more money for politicians. More specifically, it’s to give the politicians more money to dispense to those who put them in office – the city’s public employee labor unions. Consider:

    NYC spends more per prisoner annually – $167,731 – than FOUR years’ tuition at Harvard

    Here’s the poster child for the coming New York city bankruptcy. The city spends more annually per prisoner than what a full four years’ tuition would cost at Harvard. 2012 NYC per prisoner cost was an astronomical $167,731 — about $460 a day. Four years’ Harvard tuition comes to $155,564. About 86% of the NYC cost is city union labor.

    To put that into perspective, the California state government has among the highest state cost per prisoner — somewhere between $50,000 and $60,000 per year. The national state prison average annual prisoner cost was $31,286 in 2010. The NYC figure dwarfs other large city incarceration costs. Chicago is probably second at $52,925.

    I spend a lot of time discussing the disaster that is California. It’s nice to look across the country to the astonishing madness that consumes NYC. I feel better already!

  4. I’m pretty sure that there are more complaints about hotels than Airbnb. I don’t want to say anything negative about hotels too, I was trying to get a last minute cheap place to sleep and asked a few members of Airbnb. The only one that replied was some guy, who just sent me a bank account and told me to send him 50% of the money. I wrote him that he can at least give me an address or a telephone number, but the answer was “You have to send the money first.”. So I cursed him silently in front of my laptop and found a last minute hotel offer maybe 5 minutes later. So, people, use your common sense and you won’t have problems with either hotels or Airbnb.